Search DU CTLAT Blog

Monday, March 19, 2012

Tomorrow's Professor: MLA (Modern Language Association) Considers Radical Changes in the Dissertation

Rick Reis

SEATTLE -- The average humanities doctoral student takes nine years to earn a Ph.D. That fact was cited frequently here (and not with pride) at the annual meeting of the Modern Language Association. Richard E. Miller, an English professor at Rutgers University's main campus in New Brunswick, said that the nine-year period means that those finishing dissertations today started them before Facebook, Twitter, YouTube, Kindles, iPads or streaming video had been invented.

So much has changed, he said, but dissertation norms haven't, to the detriment of English and other language programs. "Are we writing books for the 19th century or preparing people to work in the 21st?" he asked.

Leaders of the MLA -- in several sessions and discussions here -- indicated that they are afraid that too many dissertations are indeed governed by out-of-date conventions, leading to the production of "proto-books" that may do little to promote scholarship and may not even be advancing the careers of graduate students. During the process, the graduate students accumulate debt and frustrations. Russell A. Berman, a professor of comparative literature and German studies at Stanford University, used his presidential address at the MLA to call for departments to find ways to cut "time to degree" for doctorates in half.

And at a standing-room-only session, leaders of a task force studying possible changes in dissertation requirements discussed some of the ideas under consideration. There was a strong sense that the traditional model of producing a several-hundred-page literary analysis dominates English and other language doctoral programs -- even though many people feel that the genre is overused and frequently ineffective. People also talked about the value of digital projects, of a series of essays, or public scholarship. Others talked about ways to change the student-committee dynamic in ways that might expedite dissertation completion.

"We are at a defining moment in higher education," said Kathleen Woodward, director of the Simpson Center for the Humanities at the University of Washington. "We absolutely have to think outside the box that the dissertation is a book or a book-in-progress."

The MLA's discussion of the dissertation is in some ways an outgrowth of a much-discussed report [3] issued by the association in 2006 about tenure and promotion practices. That report questioned the idea that producing monographs should be the determining factor in tenure decisions. When the report was released, many MLA leaders said that the ideas the association was endorsing also called for reconsideration of graduate education, and especially of the dissertation.

As part of the process of encouraging change, the MLA recently conducted a survey of its doctoral-granting departments. Among the findings:

62 percent of departments reported that their graduate schools have guidelines for dissertations, but most of those guidelines are general, dealing with issues such as timelines, composition of committees and so forth, and not dictating the form of a dissertation.

33 percent of departments have written descriptions of what kind of dissertation is expected of graduate students.

Minorities of departments have specific rules authorizing nontraditional formats for dissertations, and even smaller minorities of departments have approved a dissertation using one of those formats.

Of those with traditional dissertation length requirements, the range of minimums was 150 to 400 pages. Most maximums were 400 to 500 pages.

Nontraditional Formats Permitted and Used in Dissertations in English and Other Language Departments

Format Policy Permitting Its Use Format Approved in Last 5 Years

Digital project . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.4% . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.4%

Creative nonfiction . . . . . . . . . 8.8% . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.8%

Suite of essays . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.8% . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.7%

Fiction or poetry . . . . . . . . . . . .7.7% . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.8%

Translation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.7% . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.4%

Public scholarship . . . . . . . . . .4.4% . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.4%

Portfolio . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .2.2% . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.3%

Collaborative work . . . . . . . . . 1.1% . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. .0.6%

Sidonie Smith, professor of English at the University of Michigan and a past president of the MLA, said that the survey results demonstrated the potential for change. She said, for example, that many department leaders have in the past said that they would consider changes in dissertation requirements but for the rules of their graduate schools. In fact, there are very few graduate schools that would block change, she said.

Further, she noted that while the percentage of departments that have explicitly authorized nontraditional dissertations is small, they provide evidence that such alternatives are possible. Finally, she said that the survey showed that relatively few departments provide explicit information to graduate students on what is and is not possible. That lack of information, she said, "is disturbing."

While much of the talk here was about digital formats of scholarship, some of the possible changes in the dissertation process could also be helpful to graduate students pursuing a traditional, 250-page work of literary analysis.

David Damrosch, chair of comparative literature at Harvard University, described a reform recently instituted there that grad students in the audience seemed to find ideal. The department has started requiring that every single chapter of a dissertation be discussed, as they are produced, in a meeting attended by the author and all three committee members. Further, the department staff -- not the student -- sets up the meeting. (This is in contrast to grad students sending off copies, and receiving suggestions or silence from committee members individually.)

Damrosch said that many graduate students are delayed when some committee members don't read chapters in a timely way, and then go on to offer "totally contradictory advice, months after a draft has come in." Forcing everyone on the committee to meet in person, Damrosch said, shames them into reading the chapter on time, and to working out a common set of recommendations for the grad student.

"People are forced to focus," he said, and doctoral students "get coherent advice." The resulting revisions are much more likely to solve any problems, so that the student can keep moving forward.

More Than PDFs

Miller, of Rutgers, stressed that opening up students to digital work was a responsibility for humanities departments, given the way people increasingly communicate information. Graduate students need to learn "what it means to write for the web, with the web," which is not the same thing, he said, "as making PDFs of your [print] articles."

Whether departments want it to happen or not, the form of scholarship is going to change, he said. Rather than avoiding that, scholars should consider the ramifications, he said, by redesigning dissertations. "Once you lose the monograph, what?s the future of the long argument?" he asked. "What is the life of the mind is going to look like when it?s no longer stored on the page?" The answers will become clear when those about to become professors or public intellectuals are set free from the traditional dissertation, he said, and are encouraged to produce digital works.

Several also noted that the digital projects that might replace traditional dissertations may well be more oriented to teaching than are most monographs -- and that such an emphasis would reflect the reality that most graduate students will be finding jobs focused on teaching, not research.

Kathleen Fitzpatrick, professor of media studies at Pomona College and director of scholarly communication at the MLA, said that much more needs to change than simply telling graduate students they can prepare dissertations online. Graduate students who are doing digital work are "being given very mixed messages? from faculty members on such questions as whether they should let dissertation drafts circulate digitally in advance. Some faculty members approve of what is common practice among those who work online, while others frown upon it. Some warn graduate students that if they do so they will have a tougher time finding a publisher, while others say that online discussions about one's work can "help demonstrate that there is an audience."

Digital publishing is more collaborative than the traditional model, she said. "It's a shift from thinking about individual discrete products of scholarship" to "a more constant process of communication."

Further, these shifts require changing the way professors think about their graduate students' careers. When she has talked to many professors about the shift away from monograph dissertations, Fitzpatrick said, many seem to feel "anticipatory remorse," and think they are somehow hurting their graduate students' future careers by not encouraging them to produce what could become a book. "The problem with this is that the career this graduate student will have looks different from the careers we have expected," she said.

"It should be our jobs to support new kinds of work," she said. And for faculty members trained before the digital era, she said that means a responsibility to "learn how to read in new formats," not just to look for linear arguments over hundreds of pages.

Fitzpatrick made a comment in closing that inspired several of the questions from the audience. She said that she recently gave a talk at a digital humanities center and a graduate student told her about a project, and the dilemma of whether to approach it as a book-length writing project or a digital work. "I blurted out to do the risky thing," the digital project, Fitzpatrick said. But she quickly found herself wondering if that was wise, given that she didn't know about the support this graduate student would have. So she amended her advice a little. "The thing you have passion for is the thing you should be doing," she said. "But make sure somebody's got your back."

Grad Students as 'Canaries in the Coal Mine'

The questions from the audience were notable in that they didn't challenge the central premise of the speakers that scholarly communication is changing, and that the traditional dissertation shouldn't be the only option. But people were clearly worried about whether anybody would support graduate students during this transition period. Even with all the enthusiasm about digital humanities, many grad students or junior professors fear that it only takes one Luddite member of a dissertation or hiring committee to squelch all kinds of creativity or careers.

One graduate student asked whether the digital projects would simply be added on to already full workloads. He said that it felt like graduate students were being asked "to do double the skills in half the time."

Damrosch said that faculty members needed to replace some traditional assignments with different kinds of work. He said, for instance, that in one of his courses, he has replaced one of the major papers students were required to do with a wiki instead.

The director of graduate studies at a university -- referencing the idea of having a graduate student's back -- asked if that was really possible for anyone on a graduate committee to do. How, she asked, can an adviser today be sure that a student who does a digital dissertation will do well on the job market? "Are we asking our graduate students to be canaries in a coal mine?" she asked. Another person asked for data on how people with nontraditional dissertations do in the job market, and was told that there aren't enough people to know.

Still another professor in the audience said that the changes being discussed will happen only if elite universities make them first. "Elite universities have to have everyone's back," he said. "Harvard has to change first" because, if it does, "then my provost ... will say it's O.K."

Smith, of Michigan, said that she understood the concerns about encouraging people to break out of traditional models of scholarship. But she said she worried about the idea of saying people need to be cautious until they earn tenure. "We mentor people to be careful," she said, as graduate students and as junior faculty members. "If everyone is careful all that time, they are going to be careful after they get tenure. We have to change the academy."



NYU FRN 3-day Institute: “The Academy and the Community,” June 20-22, 2012 San Juan, Puerto Rico

Applications are now online! Learn more and apply at the link –

Application deadline:  Monday, April 16, 2012

The Faculty Resource Network (FRN) is pleased to announce an upcoming three-day institute entitled “The Academy and the Community,” which will take place from June 20-22, 2012, in San Juan, Puerto Rico. The Institute, which will be hosted by the Center for Puerto Rico, will consist of two seminars on issues around communication and collaboration between colleges and universities, and the communities that surround them.  The seminars will focus on “Citizenship” and “Empowering Women,” both topics of great interest to FRN and to the Center of Puerto Rico, which has among its primary objectives strengthening ethical values and social responsibility, and advancing the role of women in society.

The seminar on Citizenship, to be led by Jorge Benitez, professor of social work at the University of Puerto Rico, Rio Piedras, will examine how academia is promoting social responsibility, civic engagement, and service-learning opportunities.  Participants will look at the following issues:  What does it mean to promote social responsibility and service learning among students?  How can we promote democracy in on our campuses and in our communities?  What does citizenship mean to communities of people who have entered the country illegally, and what is the best way to connect with these communities?  Many FRN institutions are wrestling with these issues on their own campuses and in their communities.

The seminar on Empowering Women will be co-convened by Beverly Guy-Sheftall, founding director of the Women's Research and Resource Center and Anna Julia Cooper Professor of Women's Studies and English at Spelman College, and Margarita Benitez, co-director of Women’s Knowledge International.  This seminar will explore the connections between scholars of women’s studies and women activists—both points of intersection and points of friction.  Participants will discuss best practices for reconciling the work of scholars and activists, and bringing together their two bodies of knowledge in order to work effectively for change.

Faculty participants will be housed at the University of Puerto Rico, Rio Piedras.  Seminar sessions will be held at the Center for Puerto Rico.

Applications are now online! Learn more and apply at the link –

Application deadline:  Monday, April 16, 2012

Anne L. Ward
Assistant Director
Office of Faculty Resources
Faculty Resource Network
New York University
194 Mercer Street, 4th Floor
New York, NY 10012
F: 212.995.4101


Dillard University Registration for Summer and Fall 2012 Update

Dear Faculty,

This is a reminder that Registration for Summer and Fall 2012 will begin next Monday, March 26.

Thank you,

Robert A. Collins, Ph.D.
Dean of the College of Arts and Sciences
Dillard University


Dillard University Summer 2012 Book Orders

The following message is being sent on behalf of Provost Phyllis W. Dawkins and Ms. Lucy Green, Book Store Manager:
All book orders for Summer 2012 are due no later than Monday, April 02, 2012.  Please use the attached forms for all book orders.

Barbara M. Albert
Executive Assistant to the Provost
Office of Academic Affairs
(504) 816-4216 (office)
(504) 816-4144 (fax)


eSchool News This Week: March 19, 2012

March 19, 2012
Dennis Pierce
In this week's news: In a webinar sponsored by the International Association for K-12 Online Learning, experts gave their keys to starting or expanding a successful online or blended-learning program. And during a keynote speech at the Computer Using Educators conference in California, noted education researcher Diane Ravitch discussed both the promises and perils that technology holds for schools.
Also, teachers share their tips for using smart phones as learning tools; what robots can tell us about technology, children, and learning; and two major education associations are getting new leadership this fall.
What do you think of these stories? Share your thoughts in the comments section, or send them to me by eMail.
Dennis Pierce, Editor
Question of the Week: If you could take one PD class, what would the class cover and why would you choose this topic? For example, would you choose methods for online teaching? Incorporating more project-based learning? Learning how to integrate an iPad into the lesson? Please send your response to Online Editor Meris Stansbury at Your response may be chosen to be included in a thought round-up to be published by eSchool News. Please send your response by Friday the 23rd.

e Most Popular News Articles

e Did you miss this story?

Feds to schools: Embrace digital textbooks

e Top Story of the Week

Four keys to creating successful eLearning programsFour keys to creating successful eLearning programs
It's no secret that online and blended learning are picking up momentum nationwide--and during a recent International Association for K-12 Online Learning (iNACOL) webinar, experts offered advice for school leaders who hope to begin their own online or blended learning programs.[ Read More ]

e Week's Top Headlines

e Grant Alert of the Week

e Upcoming Webinars

Tegrity and the Flipped Classroom: Smarter Use of Technology for Improved Learning
Date: March 20, 2012
Time: 2:00pm ET / 11:00am PT
The Art of a Flipped Classroom – Turning Learning on its Head
Date: March 21, 2012
Time: 2:00pm ET / 11:00am PT
Powering the Digital Classroom: More than just Computers
Date: March 28, 2012
Time: 2:00pm ET / 11:00am PT
Make Thinking Visible
Date: April 4, 2012
Time: 2:00pm ET / 11:00am PT

e Special Reports

Performance assessment making a comeback in schoolsPerformance assessment making a comeback in schools
Spurred by a federal directive to use "multiple measures" of student success, performance assessment is reemerging as a strategy to delve more deeply into students' skills

e Follow us on...

Facebook Twitter LinkedIn


e Ed-Tech Partners Press Releases

Vendors - Don't forget to submit your press release information online:


e Whitepaper Library

Chief Provides Flexible, Engaging Classroom SolutionFunding Lecture Capture in Higher Education
Provided by: Tegrity
Chief Provides Flexible, Engaging Classroom SolutionChief Provides Flexible, Engaging Classroom Solution
Provided by: Chief
Best Practices in IT Management for SchoolsBest Practices in IT Management for Schools
Provided by: IPswitch
How to Evaluate Technology for Early LearnersHow to Evaluate Technology for Early Learners
Provided by: Hatch
Launching a Successful Interactive Whiteboard ImplementationLaunching a Successful Interactive Whiteboard Implementation
Provided by: Hitachi Solutions America Ltd.
Whitepaper - How to Modernize Your School's Bells, Overhead Paging, and Mass Notification in Times of AusterityHow to Save Money and Improve Safety by Converging Your Notification Systems
Provided by: Singlewire Software
Case study: Hamilton County Department of EducationCase study: Hamilton County Department of Education
Provided by: IBM
Decision Management for Student PerformanceDecision Management for Student Performance
Provided by: IBM
The Risks of Using Spreadsheets for Statistical AnalysisThe Risks of Using Spreadsheets for Statistical Analysis
Provided by: IBM
Chicago Public Schools manages 10,000 Macs and reduces support calls by 70%Chicago Public Schools manages 10,000 Macs and reduces support calls by 70%
Provided by: Absolute Software
Bensalem Saves $53,000 Per Year With Power ManagementHow one district saved $53,000 per year through smarter power
Provided by: Absolute Software
The Unique Challenges Facing the IT Professional in K12 Education Survey ReportThe Unique Challenges Facing the IT Professional in K12 Education Survey Report
Provided by: SchoolDude
A New Vision of Community: Lone Star College System Sees "Community" GloballyHow Lone Star College Uses Telepresence to Enhance Its Reputation--and Recruit More Students
Provided by: AT&T
Texas A&M University-Kingsville Installs Wireless in a SnapHow to keep students happy with dependable wireless
Provided by: Motorola


e Call for Submissions

eSchool News is looking for articles from the field. If you have an ed-tech success story or advice for fellow educators, click here for details on our submission categories and how you can submit your article for consideration. You can also eMail Managing Editor Laura Devaney at for more information.

e Educator's Resource Center

Succeeding in college today can be a daunting challenge for students without the necessary study skills or those with learning disabilities. Students must adapt not only to a whole new learning environment, but also to a more rigorous and advanced curriculum.
Though the economy shows signs of improvement, schools and districts are still faced with budget shortfalls and funding dilemmas. But many school leaders are finding that desktop virtualization can help them save time and energy--while providing computers to more students at a fraction of the cost.
In this latest STAR,
you'll find a collection of reports and research detailing 'Assessment Literacy,' or what educators, administrators and policy-makers should know about formative assessment, performance assessments, the importance of assessment alignment, using and understanding assessment data, and accessible testing and universal design.
One of technology's most promising aspects is that it enables teachers to collaborate and share lessons plans, teaching tips, and other helpful information--both within and across districts, states.
Engaging all stakeholders can boost your chances of success when it comes to academics--as well as fundraising. But in tough economic times, many schools must learn to do.
Communication has changed, and students and educators are increasingly using video technologies in all aspects of education.

e Get a Free Subscription

1. eCampus News - Stay up-to-date and educate yourself and your colleagues on how technology is constantly improving higher education. Get your free subscription here.
2. eClassroom News- eClassroom News is still written just for teachers and explores new curriculum and assessment tools, the latest professional development resources, case studies on how school are using multimedia in the classroom, the best new instructional resources on the internet and much, much more! Click hereto subscribe.
3. eSchool News- This monthly print and digital newspaper keeps you informed with up to the minute news concerning K-20 educational technology. Click here to subscribe.
Visit all of our education technology news websites:
eSchool News, 7920 Norfolk Ave Suite 900 . Bethesda, MD 20814
Phone: 301-913-0115 . Fax: 301-913-0119
Contents Copyright 2012 eSchool News. All rights reserved.