Search DU CTLAT Blog

Monday, June 25, 2012

Tomorrow's Professor: University Governance and Common Pool Resources


http://derekbruff.org/blogs/tomprof/2012/06/25/tp-msg-1189-university-governance-and-common-pool-resources/

University Governance and Common Pool Resources

Aligning faculty incentives to desired institutional outcomes is a challenge to university governance. One reason for this difficulty is that academic departments jointly produce and use common pool resources (CPRs). Faculty members share the costs and benefits of building and maintaining the quality of a department. Because a department?s benefits and costs are shared, there is a tendency for some faculty to minimize the time and effort devoted to improving the common pool while claiming a large a share of the pool for themselves. They may seek to freeload on the efforts of others. Department chairs will gain insights into governance by considering the resemblance between university departments and CPRs.

Most analyses of CPR management focus on solving the classic ?tragedy of the commons.? In this exemplification, herders share grazing land. They all have incentives to overgraze the shared land because the individual herder will not bear the full cost of feeding his or her herd; the cost will be largely born by other grazers whose cattle will have less grass. The common grazing land will be overused. Recognizing that analogous situations are present in academic departments will help explain why some practices exist and also help guide departmental governance.

An Academic Department as a CPR System

The shared resources in an academic department are difficult to identify because they are more abstract than natural resources. Consider the CPR nature of a department: Quality students, a vibrant intellectual environment, a support budget, and a good reputation are among the resources that faculty members share. Each individual benefits from a quality department that is jointly built. For instance, a good crop of students represents a jointly produced resource and provides joint benefits.

No single faculty member can claim total responsibility. Cohorts of good students help ensure that faculty members will be able to teach their specialty courses or perhaps have opportunities to teach in the summer or intercessions. Certainly, teaching can be more fun with a classroom of students willing and able to grasp and advance traditional course content. Better prepared students make better student workers. Similarly, a lively intellectual environment contributes to the research goals of individual faculty members and enables fruitful discussions on academic topics. A department?s reputation helps generate consulting opportunities for individual members and even contributes to promotions and external job searches. The list could go on. Within a department, faculty contribute to the web of jointly produced CPRs.

An incentive problem can arise when some faculty members attempt to use the CPRs while minimizing their efforts to produce those same resources. Faculty who extract resources from the common pool may believe they can maintain those benefits without extending their own efforts. Lags between the production of departmental resources and their visible dissipation reinforce the idea that lower effort may not reduce the CPRs. Accordingly, there are incentives for individuals to contribute little or nothing to their department?s CPRs while sharing in the benefits of ample students, intellectual energy, good reputation, and so forth. The caricature of the faculty member ignoring important duties to pursue a hobby having nothing to do with the job is well known and may be rational behavior.

Principles for Governing an Academic CPR System

Traditionally, only two solutions to inefficiencies created by CPR were considered: (1) reward individuals for the full costs and benefits of their actions (privatization), or (2) give government authority to set the rules. In a university setting both approaches imply micromanagement in the form of either developing very specific performance criteria and compensating faculty members according to their performance under those rules, or administratively dictating work duties. Both approaches are often associated with the corporate governance model. When applied to a department, these approaches are likely to be inefficient because faculty jobs are neither standardized nor routine. Attempts to make them so risk resulting in ?work to the rule? behavior, uncovered tasks, and missed opportunities.

Elinor Ostrom received the 2009 Noble Prize in economics for her analysis of successful CPR governance systems that were biologically based (such as fisheries and irrigation systems). She concluded that institutions can successfully govern CPR systems without either detailing a reward structure or centralized task assignments. She identified eight design principles that characterize successful CPR systems. To the extent that academic departments have CPR characteristics, Ostrom?s design principles

may be recognized in departmental policies and provide guidance for departmental administration. A caveat, however, is that the design principles cannot be implemented in a mechanical manner. They should be customized to fit the characteristics of individual departments.

1. Defined beneficiary of success.

In academic contexts, this principle implies that individuals who benefit from the accomplishments of a strong department must be limited. The restrictions prevent other claimants in the university from totally dissipating the rewards earned by another department?s efforts. This design principle does not negate the possibility that some benefits from one department spill over to other units, but it ensures that a certain portion remains with the department. Clear boundaries are necessary to make certain that departments can be effective units from which to launch the efforts needed.

2. Convergence between rules and environmental conditions is necessary.

In the case of academic departments, this principle implies that governance rules should conform to the characteristics of the discipline and the university. For instance, the rules governing student performance, external service, or publications should differ among departments because they function in different environments.

3. Individuals affected by the rules should have a voice in modifying the rules.

This principle is satisfied in most departments, although the degree of ?voice? does vary between strong and weak chair systems. Within university contexts this principle is important because of the variety of specialized tasks that faculty perform. When departmental standards are modified, faculty members probably know the consequences as well as or better than higher level administrators.

4. Contributions necessary to develop and use common resources should be monitored by individuals who developed and use the CPRs.

This rule puts the responsibility for monitoring activities closest to the individuals who have knowledge of those who are shirking activity and the incentive to avoid it. For instance, faculty members are likely to know the value of their colleagues? scholarship, teaching, and service better than anyone else. The principle is manifest in peer review evaluation processes.

5. Sanctions for inadequate performance should be graduated.

Suppose a faculty member is cutting office hours in order to consult?a relatively minor infraction at most universities. If no sanction occurred, the violator may decide that no one?s behavior is monitored and so others are freeriding. Thus, he or she will too. Graduated sanctions may curtail the nonconforming behavior, inform violators that others who disregard the rule will also be sanctioned, and increase the expected costs of future violations. An initial sanction might be as small as

?I noticed you missed office hours. Is anything wrong??

6. Conflict resolution mechanisms should be available.

Good administrators know there are at least two sides to every story. Yet some management models implicitly assume the existence

of an omnipotent judge. Faculty members violate rules for a variety of reasons including willful, honest mistakes, or the vagaries of circumstance. Lacking a conflict resolution mechanism, all violations would be treated the same.

7. Individuals producing CPRs should have the ability to devise their own ways of achieving ends.

This principle implies that departments should have a degree of rule-setting authority and the chair should support individual faculty members? decisions of authority. If a central administration assumed that only they have rule-setting authority, it is likely the department members will refrain from introducing new, more efficient ways of doing things.

8. Governance systems are organized in nested enterprises and each organization must conform to larger systems.

This design principle clearly applies to biological systems where interdependence is the touchstone of ecological perspective. Departments are nested within colleges, which are in turn nested within universities, which are nested in statewide systems. Establishing rules at one level that are inconsistent with rules at another level will create inefficiencies or a systems breakdown. For instance, if a department has a travel policy that differs from the university?s, faculty could build plans around a conference, only to find that their plans will not be funded.

Conclusion
Ostrom?s design principles reflect features common to many long-lasting CPR governance systems. Like other CPR systems, academic departments rely on resources that are jointly produced and shared; thus, departments must address efficiency problems common to other organizations that use CPRs. The recognition of the CPR nature of academic departments helps explain the reasons many departments are governed as they are. Chairs can also use the design principles to create and modify concrete rules and processes tailored to their unique and changing contexts.

------------------------------------

Emily A. Wickelgren is associate professor and vice chair of psychology at Sacramento State University. Nathaniel J. Blair is lecturer in psychology at Sacramento State University. John P. Blair is professor of economics at Wright State University.


References
Ostrom, E. (1990). Governing the commons: The evolution of institutions for collective action. New York, NY: Cambridge University Press.

Share/Bookmark

13 Websites That Offer Free eBooks for Teachers

13 Websites That Offer Free eBooks for Teachers


Are you looking for a way to save you and your students some money? If you’re not against going digital, try perusing these 13 websites for FREE electronic versions of the books you teach in class. On average, using one free eBook instead of a printed copy can save your class around $450!

1.
Bartleby
Bartleby publishes digital versions of thousands of free classics including literature and nonfiction.


2. E-Books Directory
E-Books Directory is home to around 1,700 free electronic textbooks, documents and lecture notes.


3. eBooks@Adelaide
The University of Adelaide in Australia offers a very user-friendly eBook search experience. You can browse the books it offers by author, title or by using the Google-powered search function.


4. Flat World Knowledge
Flat World Knowledge is the world's largest publisher of free college textbooks.


5. Free eBook-s
A free eBook search engine that allows you to search the internet for already-known eBook listings.


6. Google Books
With Google Books, you can search (shocking, I know) and preview millions of books from libraries and publishers around the world.


7. Many Books
Many Books is an index of over 29,000 free works that can be searched by author or title.


8. NeoTake
NeoTake is neat for a couple of reasons. First, this website has indexed over 5.4 million eBooks and ePrints (not all of which are free). Second, it allows you to read reviews so that you can select the best version for your class.


9. Open Culture
Open Culture provides links to 300 free eBooks including Don Quixote, Heart of Darkness, The Red Badge of Courage, Les Miserables, Animal Farm, MacBeth and The War of the Worlds.


10. Open Library
The headline on the Open Library website is, “The World's classic literature at your fingertips. Over 1,000,000 free eBook titles available.” ‘Nuff said?


11. Planet eBook
All of the electronic novels and books that are available on Planet eBook are free for you to download and share with your students and colleagues.


12. Project Gutenburg
Project Gutenberg offers 39,000 free eBooks. Some of the top downloads are The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes, Pride and Prejudice, Adventures of Huckleberry Finn, Frankenstein, Dracula and Jane Eyre.


13. Science Books Online
I’m guessing that you already have an idea of the kind of eBooks that Science Books Online offers, but in case you’re not feeling very imaginative today, this website lists free science eBooks, textbooks, lecture notes, monographs and other science-related documents.


Share/Bookmark

Thursday, June 21, 2012

Dillard Today - A Monthly E-Newsletter From Dillard University - June 2012

Dillard Today Logo PNG
A Monthly E-Newsletter From Dillard University

June 2012
________________ 

Quick Links

Alumni Links

Calendar of Events

6/20-6/24 -- National Association of Black Journalists' 2012 Convention

6/27 -- A Farewell to Interim President James Lyons, 5-6:30 p.m., Kearny Hall

7/9-7/20 -- Summer Youth Leadership Institute (grades 10-12)

7/9-8/10 -- Dillard Theatre/Art Enrichment Camp (ages 5-13)

Click here for more events.
________________

Baccalaureate Gallery

________________

Join Us Online

Facebook Logo 2Twitter Logo


Visit Our Social Media Page ________________

Contact Us

Dillard Today
2601 Gentilly Boulevard
New Orleans, LA 70122
dillardtoday@dillard.edu
________________


Welcome to the June 2012 edition of the Dillard Today E-Newsletter. The weather is heating up here in New Orleans, and folks are setting their air conditioners to full blast. But even in the middle of summer, there's plenty happening here on the Avenue of the Oaks. We were especially happy to welcome students back to campus this week for the academic Summer Session. Read on for more news from Fair Dillard. Ex fide fortis!


Sincerely,

Mona Duffel Jones
Senior Director, University Communications

A Farewell to Interim President James Lyons
The Dillard University community is invited to attend a farewell reception for Dr. James Lyons on Wednesday, June 27, as his interim presidency draws to a close. The reception will be held on the second floor of Kearny Hall from 5-6:30 p.m. A member of Dillard's board of trustees and a former president of three different universities, Dr. Lyons proudly represented Dillard throughout the 2011-2012 academic year while it searched for its next chief executive. As we look forward to July 1, when Dr. Walter Kimbrough will become the seventh president in Dillard's history, let us pause to thank Dr. Lyons and his wife Jocelyn for the leadership they brought to Dillard this year. We hope you will join us in congratulating them on a job well done.

Student Success: TFA, Public Health Leaders
 
Teach For America, the non-profit organization that enlists high-ranking college graduates to teach in poorly performing schools across the U.S., was the top employer of Dillard University's Class of 2012. Arielle Calloway, Markeecha Forcell, Ashely Leigh, Jasmine Preston, Juan Serrano (pictured) and Tess Williams have accepted offers from TFA to become corps members. They will participate in an intensive summer training institute and begin their two-year teaching commitments this fall. Congratulations to these six Dillard grads as they go out into the world and make a difference in communities around the country!

In other student news, Leatrice Wilson ('12) and Byron Caulton ('13) of Dillard's School of Public Health have been chosen to participate in the Future Public Health Leaders summer program at the University of Michigan. The program, funded by a $4.2 million grant from the Centers for Disease Control, aims to increase minority involvement in the field of public health. The program's first cohort arrived in Michigan earlier this month. Congrats to Leatrice and Byron! 


National Black Journalists' Convention

Dillard University is proud to be a part of the National Association of Black Journalists' 2012 convention this week in New Orleans.

On Tuesday, Dillard's School of Mass Communication hosted a public forum in the PSB to explore New Orleans' beleaguered public school system and seek solutions from panelists and residents. Norman Robinson of WDSU-TV moderated the discussion, and panelists included local parents, education activists, university professors and more.

On Friday, Kiki Baker-Barnes, Dillard's athletic director and head women's basketball coach, will speak at a panel called "A Brand New Game: 40 Years Since Title IX" about the impact of the landmark 1972 legislation that forever changed women's high school and collegiate athletics. Later in the day, Bernard Griffin, the Bleu Devils men's basketball coach, will be recognized at the convention's Sports Pioneer Awards Ceremony. Incoming Dillard President Walter Kimbrough will also address the convention on Friday at a panel called "In the Wake of No Child Left Behind, Where Do We Go From Here?" Fridays events will be held at the Hilton Riverside New Orleans hotel, and are only open to convention registrants. 


Theatre/Art Summer Camp, Ages 5-13

The Dillard University Department of Humanities will host its first Theatre/Art Summer Enrichment Camp for students ages 5 to 13 from July 9 to Aug. 10. The program will focus on theater, art and music and run from 8 a.m. to 4 p.m., Monday through Friday, with options for after-camp care.

The program aims to assist parents during the period of summer when many camps have ended and they find themselves at an impasse - trying to find somewhere safe, affordable, enriching and easily accessible to place their children until school begins.

Campers will act, paint, write, draw, sing, dance and play musical instruments. They will also go swimming, watch movies, and take arts-related field trips. The camp will culminate with an event on its final day that will enable students to display their art, musicianship and acting abilities to their friends and families.

The five-week camp costs $250 per child (or just $10 per day), with $25 discounts for siblings. After-camp care is available for an additional cost.

Interested parents (and volunteers and donors) are encouraged to contact Zena Ezeb in the Department of Humanities at (504) 816-4450 or (504) 816-4689 between 8 a.m. and 5 p.m., Monday through Friday, to learn more or to enroll their children. Voice messages will be returned promptly.

Alumni In Focus: Darryl Kilbert

In December 2006, Darryl Kilbert was appointed superintendent of the Orleans Parish Public School System. As chief academic/administrative officer, he is responsible for all operations of the district and for advising and making recommendations to the Board of Education. Under his direction, the school district has received an unprecedented four consecutive unqualified financial audits, achieved an average of 95 percent attendance, instituted model technology classrooms throughout the district, and reduced teacher-pupil ratios. Currently the Orleans Parish School Board has ranked first in state cohort graduation rates (students graduating in four years) for two straight years.

A retirement gala celebrating Mr. Kilbert will be held on June 30. To attend, contact Pearl Noel at (504) 304-4171 or Yolanda Johnson at (504) 330-4445.






Dillard University | 2601 Gentilly Boulevard | New Orleans | LA | 70122


Share/Bookmark

EduDemic: June 21, 2012


EduDemic


 

5 Ways To Be Better At Facebook
Posted: 20 Jun 2012 11:25 AM PDT
facebook 390 x 250
While there have recently been whispers of facebook’s demise–or at least slow kneel–until such a time that there aren’t more than nearly billion active users, it’s probably a good idea to factor the behemoth into your social media plans, whether they are personal, professional, or …

Posted: 20 Jun 2012 05:30 AM PDT
campus-technology
Higher education continues to change at a rapid pace. There are many factors that are constantly causing this, such as the increase in population and the advancement in technology.

Posted: 20 Jun 2012 05:30 AM PDT
stressbrain
Being online is stressful. You want to keep up with your never-ending Twitter stream, Facebook pals, Instagram photos, and apps. And that's just your smartphone. When you plop your butt down in front of a desktop or laptop, the digital stress grows exponentially.




Share/Bookmark

Diverse Issues in Higher Education: Commentary: Latest Assault on Black Studies Reaffirms Its Relevance


June 15, 2012

by Dr. Brandon E. Gamble

In April, Naomi Schaefer Riley penned two controversial blogs about eliminating Black studies programs. She wrote a blog post about abolishing Black studies for, of all things, poorly-written and irrelevant dissertations. What she did not let her readers know is that is the case for nearly all dissertations. The first offering of a doctoral candidate is often a hodge-podge of sound and fury, only signifying that the candidate can take feedback and psychological pain well and, under that duress, write anything that pleases the three people on the committee. There are exceptions, but I would dare to venture that most of the outstanding dissertations are from people with full fellowships or who work at the university full-time. As William Germano wrote in his 2005 book, From Dissertation to Book, “what makes a dissertation outstanding to a publisher isn’t exactly the same thing that makes it outstanding to the scholarly community.”

Black issues are not designed to help White people feel safer. Black studies were not designed to focus on White people’s interests, but to discuss issues of relevance to the Black community. Schaefer Riley asserts that Blacks fail to acknowledge any progress over the last 50 years, pointing to the election of the nation’s first Black president as evidence to the contrary. The reason the Black scholars may be stuck in 1963 is because the problems have become worse since Dr. King died, especially in the area of education.

One step forward with integration has equaled two steps back in education and economics for Blacks, and no conservative or liberal policy has done much to change that. Four hundred years of momentum of White supremacist policy via COINTELPRO, Jim Crow laws, and slavery vs. 40 years of “progress” is a hard arc to bend towards justice.

Black people are a perceived liability, yet we actually have the highest levels of education via continental African immigrants of first or second generations in the U.S. We are in the midst of a holocaust of the mind via gang violence and poverty, and we experience disproportionate incarceration numbers. Sure, having a Black president has some benefits, but for even powerful Black people, they have yet to fully materialize. Minority populations, such as Hispanics and Blacks, are even less likely to access the health care system.

The lack of critical attention to the needs of all Americans — not just those that support the conservative cause — obscures the ability of some to see how studying ways to make the lives of Black people better may actually help all people. There are different ways of thinking besides about and for Euro-American interests. The ignorant mentality that suggests that the election of the nation’s first Black president represents significant progress is the same that underscores the continued need for Black studies programs.

If the Africana studies or Black studies department dies while fighting, like the Civil Rights martyrs of the 1960s, they will at least inspire people to open their eyes. It is incredible that opponents of Black studies programs come at graduate students with a vengeance, unprovoked, like Bull Connor with dogs and hoses attacking defenseless people. It is ironic that the most privileged Blacks can catch some of the most hell for not staying in line. Sorry, but you don’t get to pick our heroes or villains, let alone give us advice.

The three major complaints Schaefer Riley cites in rebuttal, following the huge public outcry and her firing from her position with the Chronicle of Higher Education, are the facts that she is not Black and is therefore perceived as a racist, the idea that she is picking on people who are too young and inexperienced to defend themselves and the fact that she is not qualified to comment on the subject matter at all, given her lack of a Ph.D. She is right in saying these complaints are irrelevant. Calling her racist does nothing for me or for Black people, but doing something about actual racism does. I let White people of good will who do not fear a Black planet or losing their privilege deal with her as a racist. Her not having a Ph.D. might actually help her in this case, because she knows nothing of the pain and submission that people have to go through in order to earn a Ph.D.

It must be noted that Black studies programs have as many challenges as any other department in a university. Black studies scholars need to get off of their Ph.D. statues and do more in the community. I am all the more convinced they should move all the Black studies programs to independent Black universities, not state-run schools. Either way, Africana and Black studies faculty, please stand your ground and fight for Africana and Black studies departments.

— Brandon E. Gamble, Ed.D., is an assistant professor within the school psychology program at California State University Long Beach.

Share/Bookmark

Dillard University Summer 2012 Official Attendance Rosters are Due Friday, June 22nd


To:        Faculty
From:    Pam England, Registrar/Director of Records & Registration
Date:     June 21, 2012
Re:        Official Class Rosters are Due Friday, June 22nd at 5pm
Official attendance rosters should be administered by Faculty in class beginning on Tomorrow, Friday, June  22, 2012.
Those students who have not completed the clearance process have been purged.  Please print an updated roster from myDU.
Please do not make copies of your roll book.
If you have been assigned to a class you can access your class roster via myDU.  If you have not been assigned to your class or if you cannot access myDU please contact the Office of Records and Registration located in Rosenwald 116 or respond to this email.
Reminder:  Checking Attendance is mandatory.
Please indicate “NS” for No Show by the student’s name if they have not been attending class.
Return the printed rosters stating the status of each student along with your signature certifying the rosters are accurate to the Office of Records Registration by 5:00pm, Friday, June 22nd.
Check your rosters carefully! Please do not allow anyone to remain in your class who is not on your roster! Send them to the Office of Records and Registration immediately!
If you have any questions or concerns, please contact me via email.
Thanks so much!
Pam England
Registrar/Director of Records and Registration
Dillard University
2601 Gentilly Boulevard New Orleans, LA 70122
504.816.4705 (Office)
504.816.4391 (Fax)
pengland@dillard.edu
"Your Avenue of Opportunity"
Share/Bookmark